{ "schema_version": "1.1.0", "resource_release_version": "1.1.0", "release_date": "2026-10-07", "display_timezone": "America/Phoenix", "evidence_type": "observed_public_source_illustration", "records": [ { "example_id": "observed-J01", "content_type": "job_listing", "title": "EV Group Data Analyst: the opening is in Austria", "evidence_type": "observed_public_source_illustration", "intended_use": "Show how to check the exact employer job page. Do not give an overseas job an Arizona location just because the company also has an Arizona site.", "intended_timeframe": "These are the job terms shown on the employer page when it was opened and checked for this release. No separate check confirms that the job is still open.", "publication_text": "EV Group's retrieved employer page describes an entry-level, full-time Data Analyst role at its headquarters in St. Florian am Inn, Austria. It calls for a university degree in Data Science or another data-analysis area and describes industry experience in Overlay Analysis as beneficial.", "sources": [ { "source_id": "OBS-J-S01", "title": "Data Analyst (m/f/d)", "publisher": "EV Group", "url": "https://www.evgroup.com/careers/jobs/data-analyst-mfd", "publication_date": null, "publication_date_status": "unknown", "checked_at": "2026-10-06T23:58:29-07:00", "locator": "Main heading and metadata row; Requirements, first two bullets", "evidence_summary": "The employer page gives the role, Austrian location, full-time and entry-level labels, required degree, and experience described as helpful.", "access_status": "checked_accessible", "limitations": "The page was found through the employer careers page. The root agent opened it again for a separate check. No publication date is shown. This records the terms that were read. It does not promise that applications remain open or that every job term was checked." } ], "claims": [ { "claim_id": "OBS-J-C01", "text": "The employer page identifies the role as Data Analyst.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-J-S01" ], "locator": "Main heading", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The job name comes from this exact employer page." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-J-C02", "text": "The listed workplace is St. Florian am Inn, Austria, at the headquarters.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-J-S01" ], "locator": "Metadata row, location label", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The company's separate Tempe site does not make this an Arizona job." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-J-C03", "text": "The page labels the role full time.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-J-S01" ], "locator": "Metadata row, employment-time label", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft keeps the full-time label. It does not assume remote or hybrid work." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-J-C04", "text": "The page labels the role entry level.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-J-S01" ], "locator": "Metadata row, experience-level label", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The entry-level label does not remove the separate degree requirement." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-J-C05", "text": "The requirements call for a university degree in Data Science or another data-analysis area.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-J-S01" ], "locator": "Requirements, first bullet", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft keeps the choice of degree fields. It does not narrow the rule to one major." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-J-C06", "text": "Industry experience in Overlay Analysis is described as beneficial.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-J-S01" ], "locator": "Requirements, second bullet", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft keeps helpful experience separate from required experience." } ], "review": { "reviewer_type": "agent", "first_review": "NIST evidence agent followed the current employer careers-page link and checked the job heading, metadata and requirements.", "second_review": "Root agent separately opened the replacement job page and confirmed the location, labels, degree wording and beneficial-experience qualifier. The exact event timestamp was not supplied.", "checked_at": "2026-10-06T23:58:29-07:00", "status": "agent_source_and_artifact_reviews_completed", "artifact_review_status": "verified_against_finished_html", "limits": "Separate agent source checks, not human evaluation or confirmation from the employer. No application was submitted and no live vacancy status is guaranteed. Recheck before public release.", "artifact_reviewed_by": "NIST evidence agent; separate from site implementation", "artifact_review_checked_at": "2026-10-07T00:24:11-07:00", "artifact_review_summary": "Checked the generated examples.html article against this record: publication text, use and timeframe, all six claim texts and rationales, source locators and limitations, source publication dates distinct from Arizona check times, exact external source URLs, and all six matching internal claim-to-source links. This was a content and link audit, not a human participant study or a comprehensive accessibility test." }, "limitations": "This example uses a real employer page. It does not report an observed AI error. The job is in Austria. A company with Arizona sites can have jobs elsewhere. Pay and the general benefits panel were not part of these selected claims. No publication date is shown, and no separate check confirms that the job remains open.", "lesson": "Check the location of this exact job. Keep preferred experience separate from required experience. Entry level does not remove the listed requirements." }, { "example_id": "observed-D01", "content_type": "company_directory", "title": "EV Group: what the company says and where it is", "evidence_type": "observed_public_source_illustration", "intended_use": "Show a company profile that names the company as its source. Check its work and Arizona presence as separate claims.", "intended_timeframe": "These are company statements on the official pages checked for this release. They are not a promise that the details will stay correct.", "publication_text": "EV Group, abbreviated EVG, describes its work as semiconductor process solutions and equipment. Its profile lists wafer bonding, lithography, thin-wafer processing and metrology products and states that the company was founded in 1980. Its locations page lists headquarters in St. Florian am Inn, Austria, and an Arizona North America location in Tempe.", "sources": [ { "source_id": "OBS-D-S01", "title": "About EVG", "publisher": "EV Group", "url": "https://www.evgroup.com/company/about-evg", "publication_date": null, "publication_date_status": "unknown", "checked_at": "2026-10-06T23:57:47-07:00", "locator": "Short Profile, paragraphs 1-4", "evidence_summary": "The company describes who it is, its semiconductor focus, its kinds of equipment, and its founding year.", "access_status": "checked_accessible", "limitations": "This is the company's own description, not a separate test of performance. No publication date is shown. This example makes no claim about employee count or market leadership." }, { "source_id": "OBS-D-S02", "title": "Global presence", "publisher": "EV Group", "url": "https://www.evgroup.com/company/global-presence", "publication_date": null, "publication_date_status": "unknown", "checked_at": "2026-10-06T23:57:47-07:00", "locator": "EV Group Headquarters and EV Group North America - Arizona entries", "evidence_summary": "The location list shows the headquarters in Austria and a separate presence in Tempe.", "access_status": "checked_accessible", "limitations": "These are the company's own location listings. They do not show the work, staff count, or manufacturing output at each office. No publication date is shown." } ], "claims": [ { "claim_id": "OBS-D-C01", "text": "The company profile identifies EV Group with the abbreviation EVG.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-D-S01" ], "locator": "Short Profile, paragraph 1", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The company name was checked directly. It was not guessed from an unrelated business name." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-D-C02", "text": "EVG describes semiconductor process solutions and equipment as its business.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-D-S01" ], "locator": "Short Profile, paragraphs 1-2", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The wording names the company as the source. It does not claim that separate tests proved its performance." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-D-C03", "text": "Its listed equipment categories include wafer bonding, lithography, thin-wafer processing and metrology.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-D-S01" ], "locator": "Short Profile, paragraph 2", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The listed kinds of products support this specific description. They do not prove that the Arizona site makes chips." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-D-C04", "text": "The company states that it was founded in 1980.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-D-S01" ], "locator": "Short Profile, paragraph 4", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "minor", "rationale": "This history comes from the company. It does not claim that its Arizona office existed at that time." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-D-C05", "text": "Its locations page places the headquarters in St. Florian am Inn, Austria.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-D-S02" ], "locator": "EV Group Headquarters entry", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The headquarters is kept separate from the local office." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-D-C06", "text": "Its Arizona North America location is listed in Tempe, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-D-S02" ], "locator": "EV Group North America - Arizona entry", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The company's official list supports saying it has an Arizona presence. It does not support claims about local output or staff." } ], "review": { "reviewer_type": "agent", "first_review": "NIST evidence agent opened the official sources and checked claim wording and locators.", "second_review": "Root agent independently opened these official sources and reported confirmation in the task message. The exact event timestamp was not supplied.", "checked_at": "2026-10-06T23:57:47-07:00", "status": "agent_source_and_artifact_reviews_completed", "limits": "Agent-assisted desk review, not human evaluation, independent expert certification, or evidence of publishing outcomes. Recheck the sources before public release.", "artifact_review_status": "verified_against_finished_html", "artifact_reviewed_by": "NIST evidence agent; separate from site implementation", "artifact_review_checked_at": "2026-10-07T00:24:11-07:00", "artifact_review_summary": "Checked the generated examples.html article against this record: publication text, use and timeframe, all six claim texts and rationales, source locators and limitations, source publication dates distinct from Arizona check times, exact external source URLs, and all six matching internal claim-to-source links. This was a content and link audit, not a human participant study or a comprehensive accessibility test." }, "limitations": "These statements come from the company website. The pages do not show publication dates. They are not separate proof of performance, market rank, local manufacturing, or that all company jobs are in Arizona. This is an example using real sources, not an observed AI error or a test score.", "lesson": "Check what a company supplies and where each site is. Keep the company's worldwide work, headquarters, and Arizona presence separate." }, { "example_id": "observed-N01", "content_type": "business_news", "title": "TSMC Arizona: a November 2024 award announcement", "evidence_type": "observed_public_source_illustration", "intended_use": "Show how to report a past funding announcement. Keep the maximum amounts, plans, and rules for payment clear.", "intended_timeframe": "This covers what the archived NIST release announced on November 15, 2024. It does not report current project or payment status.", "publication_text": "An archived NIST release dated November 15, 2024 says the U.S. Department of Commerce awarded TSMC Arizona Corporation up to $6.6 billion in direct funding. It linked the award to a planned investment of more than $65 billion across three Phoenix fabrication facilities and said disbursement would depend on project milestones.", "sources": [ { "source_id": "OBS-N-S01", "title": "TSMC Arizona CHIPS incentives award announcement", "publisher": "NIST / U.S. Department of Commerce", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2024/11/biden-harris-administration-announces-chips-incentives-award-tsmc-arizona", "publication_date": "2024-11-15", "publication_date_status": "known", "checked_at": "2026-10-06T23:57:47-07:00", "locator": "Release date and first two body paragraphs", "evidence_summary": "The archived announcement keeps the award amount, private investment plan, location, and payments tied to project milestones separate.", "access_status": "checked_accessible", "limitations": "This page is marked as an archived announcement. Its update date is October 6, 2025. It does not show current investment totals, completed chip plants, jobs created, or money already paid." } ], "claims": [ { "claim_id": "OBS-N-C01", "text": "The archived release is dated November 15, 2024.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-N-S01" ], "locator": "Date below the headline", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "This uses the announcement date, not the later page-update date." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-N-C02", "text": "The release says Commerce awarded funding to TSMC Arizona Corporation.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-N-S01" ], "locator": "First body paragraph", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The claim is about the named recipient and what the agency announced." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-N-C03", "text": "The announced direct funding was up to $6.6 billion.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-N-S01" ], "locator": "First body paragraph", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft keeps the maximum amount and type of funding. An award does not mean the full amount was paid." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-N-C04", "text": "The release described a planned private investment of more than $65 billion.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-N-S01" ], "locator": "Second body paragraph", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The planned private investment stays separate from money spent and from the public award." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-N-C05", "text": "The investment plan in that release concerned three fabs in Phoenix.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-N-S01" ], "locator": "Second body paragraph", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The number comes from the historical plan. It is not presented as today's count of sites." }, { "claim_id": "OBS-N-C06", "text": "The release tied disbursement to completion of project milestones.", "source_ids": [ "OBS-N-S01" ], "locator": "Second body paragraph", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "This condition avoids a false impression that all the awarded money had already been paid." } ], "review": { "reviewer_type": "agent", "first_review": "NIST evidence agent opened the official sources and checked claim wording and locators.", "second_review": "Root agent independently opened these official sources and reported confirmation in the task message. The exact event timestamp was not supplied.", "checked_at": "2026-10-06T23:57:47-07:00", "status": "agent_source_and_artifact_reviews_completed", "limits": "Agent-assisted desk review, not human evaluation, independent expert certification, or evidence of publishing outcomes. Recheck the sources before public release.", "artifact_review_status": "verified_against_finished_html", "artifact_reviewed_by": "NIST evidence agent; separate from site implementation", "artifact_review_checked_at": "2026-10-07T00:24:11-07:00", "artifact_review_summary": "Checked the generated examples.html article against this record: publication text, use and timeframe, all six claim texts and rationales, source locators and limitations, source publication dates distinct from Arizona check times, exact external source URLs, and all six matching internal claim-to-source links. This was a content and link audit, not a human participant study or a comprehensive accessibility test." }, "limitations": "An agent checked this example of an archived announcement. It is not a current investment report or a financial audit. The review did not check later changes to plans, program terms, construction, or payments. It does not claim that the source publisher or an AI system made an error.", "lesson": "An announced award, a private investment plan, and money already paid are different claims. Keep the original date, limits, and rules for payment." } ] }