{ "schema_version": "1.1.0", "resource_release_version": "1.1.0", "release_date": "2026-10-07", "display_timezone": "America/Phoenix", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "records": [ { "case_id": "practice-J01", "short_id": "J01", "content_type": "job_listing", "title": "Invented salary", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a current job listing that sends readers to the right employer opening.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "People deciding whether, where, and how to apply for a job.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-J01-source-1", "title": "Test Fixture Technician | CI-217", "publisher": "Cindercoil Instruments", "url": "https://cindercoil-instruments.example/careers/CI-217", "publication_date": "2026-10-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Vacancy page: Identity, Work and qualifications, and Status sections; complete supplied page", "text": "Identity\nEmployer: Cindercoil Instruments. Role: Test Fixture Technician. Requisition: CI-217.\nWork and qualifications\nFull-time employment. On-site work in Mesa, Arizona. At least one year of hands-on electronics assembly experience is required.\nTasks include assembling test fixtures and recording inspection results.\nStatus\nThis opening is accepting applications as of October 6, 2026. Apply from this requisition page.\nEnd of supplied vacancy page.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-cindercoil-instruments", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. The full job page has no pay field or amount. This tells us only what this posting says. Other employer material might state pay. The opening status applies only to the review date in this case." } ], "draft": "Cindercoil Instruments lists a Test Fixture Technician opening under requisition CI-217. This is a full-time, on-site position in Mesa, Arizona. The published salary is $68,000 to $78,000 a year. At least one year of hands-on electronics assembly experience is required. The employer marks CI-217 open on October 6, 2026.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": true, "answer": { "summary": "Keep the draft on Hold because no source supports its pay range. Keep the job terms that have support. Replace the made-up pay with a statement about what this posting does not say. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-J01-claim-1", "original_text": "Cindercoil Instruments lists a Test Fixture Technician opening under requisition CI-217.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J01-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Identity: employer, role, and requisition", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The employer, job title, and job ID name the same opening. A similar title alone would not prove that a source is about this job.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Cindercoil Instruments lists a Test Fixture Technician opening under requisition CI-217.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J01-claim-2", "original_text": "This is a full-time, on-site position in Mesa, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J01-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Work and qualifications: first two sentences", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The job type, work schedule, and city match the posting. Each could change whether someone applies, so each is Material.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "This is a full-time, on-site position in Mesa, Arizona.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J01-claim-3", "original_text": "The published salary is $68,000 to $78,000 a year.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J01-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Complete supplied vacancy page: no compensation field or figure", "source_support": "unsupported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The right employer posting is a good source for stated pay, but it gives no salary. Even a current, suitable source may not support a number. Do not treat the made-up range as an estimate or a promise from the employer.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "The supplied employer posting does not state salary or hourly pay.", "recheck_instruction": "Remove the made-up range from every place it appears, including headings and pay fields. Read the full posting to check the statement about missing pay. Check the final text again. Limit the finding to this posting." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J01-claim-4", "original_text": "At least one year of hands-on electronics assembly experience is required.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J01-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Work and qualifications: experience requirement", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft keeps the required length and kind of hands-on experience. Calling it preferred would change who qualifies.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "At least one year of hands-on electronics assembly experience is required.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J01-claim-5", "original_text": "The employer marks CI-217 open on October 6, 2026.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J01-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Status: accepting applications as of October 6, 2026", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The date limits the claim that the job is open. It does not promise that the job stays open after that date.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "The employer marks CI-217 open on October 6, 2026.", "recheck_instruction": "Check that the open status is for CI-217 and keep the review date. For a real listing on a later date, check the employer page again before saying the job is open." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Cindercoil Instruments lists a Test Fixture Technician opening under requisition CI-217. This is a full-time, on-site position in Mesa, Arizona. At least one year of hands-on electronics assembly experience is required. The supplied employer posting does not state salary or hourly pay. The employer marks CI-217 open on October 6, 2026.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "Leave out the pay sentence. Leave the pay field blank or mark it Unknown. Check that no made-up amount remains.", "Another suitable pay source could support a new claim. It must describe the same role and be labeled clearly. This case gives you no such source." ], "unresolved_issues": [], "lesson": "If a field has no value, do not fill it with a number that sounds right. Removing made-up pay is a fix. Check that the final text really removes it." } }, { "case_id": "practice-J02", "short_id": "J02", "content_type": "job_listing", "title": "Changed work arrangement", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a current job listing that sends readers to the right employer opening.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "People deciding whether, where, and how to apply for a job.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-J02-source-1", "title": "Automation Support Specialist | FL-302", "publisher": "Fennec Loop Robotics", "url": "https://fennec-loop-robotics.example/careers/FL-302", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Vacancy page: Role, Workplace, and Employment sections", "text": "Role\nFennec Loop Robotics is accepting applications for Automation Support Specialist, requisition FL-302, as of October 6, 2026.\nWorkplace\nHybrid role based in Tucson, Arizona. Three days each week at our Tucson workplace and two days working remotely. The employee must be able to commute to the Tucson workplace.\nEmployment\nFull-time employment. The role supports customer deployments during Arizona daytime business hours.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-fennec-loop-robotics", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. These terms apply only to FL-302. Hybrid work does not mean someone may work fully remotely or from any Arizona city." } ], "draft": "Fennec Loop Robotics is hiring an Automation Support Specialist under requisition FL-302. The job is fully remote and open to applicants anywhere in Arizona without a commute requirement. This is a full-time position supporting customer deployments during Arizona daytime business hours.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "Keep Hold because the draft changes a hybrid job in Tucson into fully remote work from anywhere in Arizona. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-J02-claim-1", "original_text": "Fennec Loop Robotics is hiring an Automation Support Specialist under requisition FL-302.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J02-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Role: employer, title, requisition, and open status", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft names the correct current opening in this case.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Fennec Loop Robotics is hiring an Automation Support Specialist under requisition FL-302.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J02-claim-2", "original_text": "The job is fully remote and open to applicants anywhere in Arizona without a commute requirement.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J02-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Workplace: hybrid Tucson arrangement and commute requirement", "source_support": "conflicting", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The source says three days at the workplace, so fully remote is wrong. This change could cause someone to apply for a job or plan a move that does not fit their needs.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "The job is hybrid in Tucson, Arizona, with three workplace days and two remote days each week; the employee must be able to commute to Tucson.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the city, days at the workplace, remote days, and commute rule with the Workplace section. Remove fully remote labels from every field. Record a new check of the corrected text." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J02-claim-3", "original_text": "This is a full-time position supporting customer deployments during Arizona daytime business hours.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J02-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Employment: both sentences", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "These job terms match the source. They may stay after review.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "This is a full-time position supporting customer deployments during Arizona daytime business hours.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Fennec Loop Robotics is hiring an Automation Support Specialist under requisition FL-302. The full-time role is hybrid in Tucson, Arizona, with three workplace days and two remote days each week; the employee must be able to commute to Tucson. It supports customer deployments during Arizona daytime business hours.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "A shorter label such as \"Hybrid in Tucson; three workplace days weekly\" can work if the commute rule stays visible in the listing or right beside its terms." ], "unresolved_issues": [], "lesson": "The city, remote-work rule, and commute rule each matter. A broad remote label cannot replace the actual schedule." } }, { "case_id": "practice-J03", "short_id": "J03", "content_type": "job_listing", "title": "Wrong employer", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a current job listing that sends readers to the right employer opening.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "People deciding whether, where, and how to apply for a job.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-J03-source-1", "title": "Mica Tern Automation | Controls Engineer | MT-084", "publisher": "Mica Tern Automation", "url": "https://roles-lantern.example/tenants/mica-tern/jobs/MT-084", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Tenant header, role details, and Apply destination", "text": "Tenant: mica-tern. Employer: Mica Tern Automation.\nRole: Controls Engineer. Requisition: MT-084. Status: Open on October 6, 2026.\nLocation and arrangement: Chandler, Arizona; full-time, on-site.\nApply destination: https://roles-lantern.example/tenants/mica-tern/jobs/MT-084/apply", "source_origin_group": "fictional-mica-tern-employer", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This case names mica-tern as the hiring account approved by the employer. The hiring platform serves more than one employer." }, { "source_id": "practice-J03-source-2", "title": "Oriole Flux Fabrication | Controls Engineer | OF-084", "publisher": "Oriole Flux Fabrication", "url": "https://roles-lantern.example/tenants/oriole-flux/jobs/OF-084", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Tenant header, role details, and Apply destination", "text": "Tenant: oriole-flux. Employer: Oriole Flux Fabrication.\nRole: Controls Engineer. Requisition: OF-084. Status: Open on October 6, 2026.\nLocation and arrangement: Phoenix, Arizona; full-time, on-site.\nApply destination: https://roles-lantern.example/tenants/oriole-flux/jobs/OF-084/apply", "source_origin_group": "fictional-oriole-flux-employer", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This is a different employer and job ID, even though the job title and hiring platform are the same." } ], "draft": "Mica Tern Automation is hiring a Controls Engineer under requisition OF-084. The role is full-time and on-site in Chandler, Arizona. Apply through https://roles-lantern.example/tenants/oriole-flux/jobs/OF-084/apply", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "Keep Hold because the draft mixes one employer's description with another employer's job ID and application link. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-J03-claim-1", "original_text": "Mica Tern Automation is hiring a Controls Engineer under requisition OF-084.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J03-source-1", "practice-J03-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Both sources: tenant, employer, title, and requisition", "source_support": "partly_supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "Source 1 gives this employer and title. But job ID OF-084 belongs to the other employer in source 2. The same title does not make them the same job.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "Mica Tern Automation is hiring a Controls Engineer under requisition MT-084.", "recheck_instruction": "Check the employer, its approved hiring account, and the job ID together against source 1. Remove OF-084 from the record, page details, and final text." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J03-claim-2", "original_text": "The role is full-time and on-site in Chandler, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J03-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Role details: location and arrangement", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The location and work schedule belong to the intended Mica Tern job. Keep them linked to MT-084. Do not use them for the other employer.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "The role is full-time and on-site in Chandler, Arizona.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J03-claim-3", "original_text": "Apply through https://roles-lantern.example/tenants/oriole-flux/jobs/OF-084/apply", "source_ids": [ "practice-J03-source-1", "practice-J03-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Both sources: Apply destination", "source_support": "conflicting", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "This application link goes to the Oriole Flux account and job ID. A link that works on a shared platform may still lead to the wrong job.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "Apply through https://roles-lantern.example/tenants/mica-tern/jobs/MT-084/apply", "recheck_instruction": "Match the corrected link to the intended employer's Apply link and hiring account. In a real check, follow the employer's link and any redirect before recording where it ends." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Mica Tern Automation is hiring a Controls Engineer under requisition MT-084. The role is full-time and on-site in Chandler, Arizona. Apply through https://roles-lantern.example/tenants/mica-tern/jobs/MT-084/apply", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "You could write a separate Oriole Flux listing if that is the intended employer. Review it using its own identity and Phoenix terms throughout. Do not just change the name on the mixed record." ], "unresolved_issues": [], "lesson": "On a shared hiring site, check the employer, hiring account, and job ID together. Similar titles are a reason to check more closely. They do not prove two jobs are the same." } }, { "case_id": "practice-J04", "short_id": "J04", "content_type": "job_listing", "title": "Expired opening", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Put this record on the current jobs board and invite people to apply on October 6, 2026. Do not use it as an archive or a historical note.", "intended_timeframe": "Jobs open on October 6, 2026, Arizona time.", "audience": "People deciding whether, where, and how to apply for a job.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-J04-source-1", "title": "Preserved vacancy page: Process Technician | BG-122", "publisher": "Brindle Gauge Systems", "url": "https://brindle-gauge-systems.example/archive/2026-09-21/BG-122", "publication_date": "2026-09-21", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Preserved September 21 vacancy: Role, Work, and Applications", "text": "Role\nBrindle Gauge Systems lists Process Technician, requisition BG-122.\nWork\nFull-time, on-site role in Chandler, Arizona.\nApplications\nApplications are being accepted through the BG-122 application page.\nPreserved page date: September 21, 2026. This is an archived copy, not a current status page.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-brindle-gauge-systems", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This is a dated copy of made-up evidence. It shows what the posting said on September 21. It does not show whether the job is open now." }, { "source_id": "practice-J04-source-2", "title": "Current requisition status | BG-122", "publisher": "Brindle Gauge Systems", "url": "https://brindle-gauge-systems.example/careers/BG-122/status", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Status record: Closed date and current application status", "text": "Employer: Brindle Gauge Systems. Requisition: BG-122.\nClosed date: September 30, 2026.\nStatus on October 6, 2026: Closed. This requisition is no longer accepting applications.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-brindle-gauge-systems", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This source says BG-122 closed in this case. It does not show whether another job with a similar title is open." } ], "draft": "The September 21 employer posting lists Process Technician BG-122 at Brindle Gauge Systems. That posting describes a full-time, on-site role in Chandler, Arizona. That posting says applications are being accepted through the BG-122 application page.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "Keep Hold for use on a current jobs board. The draft matches the old posting, but newer evidence says the job closed. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-J04-claim-1", "original_text": "The September 21 employer posting lists Process Technician BG-122 at Brindle Gauge Systems.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J04-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Preserved vacancy: Role and preserved page date", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "stale_for_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "This sentence correctly names an old posting. But placing it on a current jobs board would invite people to apply now. Source 2 says it later closed. The old statement cannot support that current use.", "resolution_action": "qualified", "corrected_text": "Historical listing: Brindle Gauge Systems listed Process Technician BG-122 on September 21, 2026.", "recheck_instruction": "Remove this record from the current jobs board, or change its use to a historical note. Check the role against source 1 and the closure against source 2. Review the full new context." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J04-claim-2", "original_text": "That posting describes a full-time, on-site role in Chandler, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J04-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Preserved vacancy: Work", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "stale_for_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The job terms match the old page. They describe that past job. Accurate old terms do not make a closed job fit a current jobs board.", "resolution_action": "qualified", "corrected_text": "The historical posting described full-time, on-site work in Chandler, Arizona.", "recheck_instruction": "Keep these terms only in a clearly labeled historical note. Remove the current-job category, open label, and requests to apply." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J04-claim-3", "original_text": "That posting says applications are being accepted through the BG-122 application page.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J04-source-1", "practice-J04-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Source 1: Applications; source 2: Closed date and current status", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "stale_for_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "Source 1 supports what the September 21 posting said. Source 2 says the job later closed. Supported here means the report of the old posting is accurate. It does not mean applications are open now.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "The employer's October 6 status record says BG-122 closed on September 30, 2026 and is no longer accepting applications.", "recheck_instruction": "Match the closure date and job ID to source 2. Remove every request to apply for this job. If you keep a historical note, record its new use." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Historical listing: Brindle Gauge Systems listed Process Technician BG-122 on September 21, 2026. The historical posting described full-time, on-site work in Chandler, Arizona. The employer's October 6 status record says BG-122 closed on September 30, 2026 and is no longer accepting applications.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold while the record is shown as a current opening.", "Choose Withdraw or reject for the current jobs board and keep the reason.", "Choose Ready for human approval only for a historical note, after checking the closure wording and removal of prompts to apply now." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "Withdraw the listing from the current jobs board. Keep a record of the fix or removal. You do not need replacement job text.", "Use the suggested final text only as a historical note. Change the stated use and remove it from current job listings first." ], "unresolved_issues": [ "The sources do not show another job ID that is open now. A similar title does not prove there is a replacement opening." ], "lesson": "A summary can match its source and still be wrong for the time of publication. Use historical wording only where the page and its purpose are clearly historical." } }, { "case_id": "practice-J05", "short_id": "J05", "content_type": "job_listing", "title": "Conflicting terms", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a current job listing that sends readers to the right employer opening.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "People deciding whether, where, and how to apply for a job.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-J05-source-1", "title": "Maintenance Controls Engineer | AT-061", "publisher": "Aster Thimble Automation", "url": "https://aster-thimble-automation.example/careers/AT-061", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Career page: Identity, Worksite, and Base pay", "text": "Employer: Aster Thimble Automation. Requisition: AT-061. Title: Maintenance Controls Engineer.\nWorksite: Tempe, Arizona; full-time, on-site.\nBase pay: $90,000 to $100,000 per year.\nEffective date: October 6, 2026. Opening status: Accepting applications.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-aster-thimble-automation", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This is a current page owned by the employer. Nothing in this case says it replaces the other current pay document." }, { "source_id": "practice-J05-source-2", "title": "Recruiting brief | AT-061", "publisher": "Aster Thimble Automation", "url": "https://aster-thimble-automation.example/recruiting/AT-061-brief", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Recruiting brief: requisition, worksite, and annual base pay", "text": "Employer recruiting brief. Requisition: AT-061. Title: Maintenance Controls Engineer.\nFull-time, on-site in Tempe, Arizona. Accepting applications.\nAnnual base pay: $96,000 to $108,000.\nEffective date: October 6, 2026. This brief provides no precedence rule for conflicting employer publications.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-aster-thimble-automation", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This is another current employer document with the same effective date. Nothing says which document replaces the other. Its pay range disagrees with source 1 in a way that matters to readers." } ], "draft": "Aster Thimble Automation is hiring a Maintenance Controls Engineer under requisition AT-061. This is a full-time, on-site job in Tempe, Arizona. The employer's current base-pay range is $90,000 to $100,000 per year.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "Keep the pay claim on Hold. Two equally current employer sources disagree, and neither is said to replace the other. The suggested final text removes the disputed pay amounts. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-J05-claim-1", "original_text": "Aster Thimble Automation is hiring a Maintenance Controls Engineer under requisition AT-061.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J05-source-1", "practice-J05-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Both sources: employer, role, requisition, and status", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "Both sources name the same job and say it is open now. The pay conflict does not remove that support.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Aster Thimble Automation is hiring a Maintenance Controls Engineer under requisition AT-061.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J05-claim-2", "original_text": "This is a full-time, on-site job in Tempe, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J05-source-1", "practice-J05-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Both sources: worksite and employment type", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "Both suitable employer sources support these job terms.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "This is a full-time, on-site job in Tempe, Arizona.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J05-claim-3", "original_text": "The employer's current base-pay range is $90,000 to $100,000 per year.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J05-source-1", "practice-J05-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Source 1: Base pay; source 2: Annual base pay; both effective dates", "source_support": "conflicting", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "Two current, suitable sources disagree on pay. There is no basis here to pick one, average them, or call the higher range a correction.", "resolution_action": "removed", "corrected_text": "", "recheck_instruction": "Get a recorded answer from the employer about pay for AT-061, or remove the pay numbers from the text and every pay field. Keep a record of the conflict and check the removal. Do not mark either original range as confirmed." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Aster Thimble Automation is hiring a Maintenance Controls Engineer under requisition AT-061. This is a full-time, on-site job in Tempe, Arizona.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "If the story needs to report the conflict, say which employer document gives each range. Recheck those exact source links and words. Do not present either range as the pay that applies.", "Keep the whole listing on Hold until the employer explains the pay if leaving it out would mislead readers." ], "unresolved_issues": [ "These sources do not settle which pay range applies. Keep that gap in the record even if removing the pay claim makes the shorter listing usable." ], "lesson": "Keep a record when sources disagree. Do not guess. Removing a disputed claim may make a narrower description usable, but it does not settle the source conflict." } }, { "case_id": "practice-J06", "short_id": "J06", "content_type": "job_listing", "title": "Source identity not confirmed", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a current job listing that sends readers to the right employer opening.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "People deciding whether, where, and how to apply for a job.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-J06-source-1", "title": "Claimed Cobalt Thistle recruiting page", "publisher": "Unverified page claiming to represent Cobalt Thistle Photonics", "url": "https://cobalt-thistle-hiring.example/jobs/CT-44", "publication_date": null, "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Claimed employer header, opening details, and recruitment contact", "text": "Header: Cobalt Thistle Photonics Recruitment.\nNow hiring: Optical Assembly Technician, requisition CT-44.\nWork location: Mesa, Arizona. Arrangement: Full-time, on-site.\nApplicants are instructed to use the recruitment form on this page.\nThe page gives no publication date. The supplied packet contains no employer link to this page and no verifiable authorization for its recruitment operator.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-unverified-ct-recruiting-page", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. You can read these words in the case. But the claimed employer identity, its approval of this page, and the current job status are not proven. The page design or URL proves neither fraud nor that the page is genuine." }, { "source_id": "practice-J06-source-2", "title": "Company careers navigation", "publisher": "Cobalt Thistle Photonics", "url": "https://cobalt-thistle-photonics.example/careers", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Current careers navigation and named recruiting operator", "text": "Company careers navigation, October 6, 2026.\nOur current careers destination is https://cedarkey-careers.example/cobalt-thistle.\nNamed recruitment operator: CedarKey Careers.\nThis navigation page makes no statement about CT-44 or the operator of cobalt-thistle-hiring.example.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-cobalt-thistle-company", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This case identifies the navigation page as genuine company material. It gives a route for checking. It does not prove that the other page is approved or a fraud, or that CT-44 exists." } ], "draft": "Cobalt Thistle Photonics is hiring an Optical Assembly Technician under requisition CT-44. This is a full-time, on-site position in Mesa, Arizona. Apply using the form at https://cobalt-thistle-hiring.example/jobs/CT-44", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "Keep the whole listing on Hold. The page contains the draft's words, but its link to the employer and the job's current status are not confirmed. This does not prove the page is a fraud. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-J06-claim-1", "original_text": "Cobalt Thistle Photonics is hiring an Optical Assembly Technician under requisition CT-44.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J06-source-1", "practice-J06-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Source 1: claimed header and opening; source 2: authorized careers destination", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "unresolved", "timeframe_fit": "unknown", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The page contains these words, so the text matches. But no employer link or approval connects the page to the company. The company navigation points elsewhere. There is also no date showing that the job is still open.", "resolution_action": "unresolved", "corrected_text": "", "recheck_instruction": "Use the company's known careers page, or get a recorded answer through a contact route you confirmed separately. Check who runs the page, the job ID, and its current status before listing it. These supplied sources cannot finish that check." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J06-claim-2", "original_text": "This is a full-time, on-site position in Mesa, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J06-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Claimed page: work location and arrangement", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "unresolved", "timeframe_fit": "unknown", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The wording matches the page, but no suitable employer source confirms these terms. Copying the words accurately does not prove who posted them or whether they are current.", "resolution_action": "unresolved", "corrected_text": "", "recheck_instruction": "After confirming that the employer approves this page, check the actual CT-44 terms in the employer's known source. Until then, keep this claim unresolved." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J06-claim-3", "original_text": "Apply using the form at https://cobalt-thistle-hiring.example/jobs/CT-44", "source_ids": [ "practice-J06-source-1", "practice-J06-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Source 1: recruitment form instruction; source 2: named recruiting operator and destination", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "unresolved", "timeframe_fit": "unknown", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The page asks people to apply. But the company material does not confirm this form as an approved place to apply. That gap needs a check. It does not by itself prove someone is posing as the employer.", "resolution_action": "unresolved", "corrected_text": "", "recheck_instruction": "Confirm the application link through the employer's known route. In a real review, check any redirects too. Do not send applicants to this form while its identity is still in doubt." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Listing withheld: employer authorization, the claimed opening, and the application destination have not been established.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until separate evidence confirms employer approval, the job ID, and current terms.", "Choose Withdraw or reject and keep the record of the identity question.", "The supplied sources alone cannot make this public job ad Ready." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "Withdraw or reject the listing without calling it a fraud.", "A story about an unconfirmed hiring page would need a different purpose and its own review. It would not approve this job ad." ], "unresolved_issues": [ "Who runs the hiring page, and whether the employer approves it.", "Whether CT-44 is a current job in this made-up case, and what its terms are.", "Whether the employer approves the form as a place to apply." ], "lesson": "Check that the source is linked to the right employer. A page that looks official, or a web address that sounds right, does not prove that link. A different domain does not prove fraud either." } }, { "case_id": "practice-J07", "short_id": "J07", "content_type": "job_listing", "title": "Changed job requirements", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a current job listing that sends readers to the right employer opening.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "People deciding whether, where, and how to apply for a job.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-J07-source-1", "title": "Field Service Technician | RF-208", "publisher": "Rivet Finch Vacuum Services", "url": "https://rivet-finch-vacuum.example/careers/RF-208", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Vacancy: Identity and Required and preferred qualifications", "text": "Identity\nRivet Finch Vacuum Services seeks a Field Service Technician, requisition RF-208, based in Mesa, Arizona. Open as of October 6, 2026.\nRequired and preferred qualifications\nAt least two years of vacuum-equipment maintenance experience is required.\nAn associate degree in an electronics or mechanical field is preferred, not required.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-rivet-finch-vacuum", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. Required experience and preferred education are separate rules. The source gives no exceptions or rule for using other experience in place of what is stated." } ], "draft": "Rivet Finch Vacuum Services seeks a Field Service Technician under requisition RF-208 in Mesa, Arizona. Applicants must hold an associate degree in an electronics or mechanical field. No prior vacuum-equipment maintenance experience is necessary.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "Keep Hold because the draft adds a degree requirement and removes required experience. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-J07-claim-1", "original_text": "Rivet Finch Vacuum Services seeks a Field Service Technician under requisition RF-208 in Mesa, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J07-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Identity: employer, role, requisition, and city", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft names the right job and location.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Rivet Finch Vacuum Services seeks a Field Service Technician under requisition RF-208 in Mesa, Arizona.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J07-claim-2", "original_text": "Applicants must hold an associate degree in an electronics or mechanical field.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J07-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Required and preferred qualifications: degree sentence", "source_support": "conflicting", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft turns a preference into a requirement. It could stop people who meet the actual rules from applying.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "An associate degree in an electronics or mechanical field is preferred, not required.", "recheck_instruction": "Keep both preferred and not required in the new wording. Check skill tags and advice to applicants for the same error." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J07-claim-3", "original_text": "No prior vacuum-equipment maintenance experience is necessary.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J07-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Required and preferred qualifications: experience sentence", "source_support": "conflicting", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The source requires at least two years of this kind of maintenance work. Saying it is not required changes who qualifies.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "At least two years of vacuum-equipment maintenance experience is required.", "recheck_instruction": "Check the minimum time, kind of experience, and required status. Make sure the final text includes the rule. Then record the new check." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Rivet Finch Vacuum Services seeks a Field Service Technician under requisition RF-208 in Mesa, Arizona. At least two years of vacuum-equipment maintenance experience is required. An associate degree in an electronics or mechanical field is preferred, not required.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "Use separate Required and Preferred lists. Keep the same minimum experience and make clear that the degree is optional." ], "unresolved_issues": [], "lesson": "Words such as not, required, and preferred change the meaning. Keep them in a short summary." } }, { "case_id": "practice-J08", "short_id": "J08", "content_type": "job_listing", "title": "Changed pay amount and time unit", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a current job listing that sends readers to the right employer opening.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "People deciding whether, where, and how to apply for a job.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-J08-source-1", "title": "Calibration Technician | SF-319", "publisher": "Solstice Finch Metrology", "url": "https://solstice-finch-metrology.example/careers/SF-319", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Vacancy: Role, Compensation, and Schedule", "text": "Role\nSolstice Finch Metrology is hiring a Calibration Technician, requisition SF-319, in Glendale, Arizona.\nCompensation\nBase pay: $28 to $34 per hour. This is an hourly base rate, excluding any overtime payments.\nSchedule\nFull-time role, scheduled for 40 hours per week. Opening confirmed in this fictional page as of October 6, 2026.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-solstice-finch-metrology", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. The page does not give annual pay, paid weeks per year, overtime hours, or promised yearly earnings." } ], "draft": "Solstice Finch Metrology is hiring a Calibration Technician under requisition SF-319 in Glendale, Arizona. The listed base salary is $28,000 to $34,000 per year. The full-time schedule is 40 hours per week.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "Keep Hold because the draft changes both the pay amount and its time unit. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-J08-claim-1", "original_text": "Solstice Finch Metrology is hiring a Calibration Technician under requisition SF-319 in Glendale, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J08-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Role: employer, role, requisition, and city", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The job and location match the current source in this case.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Solstice Finch Metrology is hiring a Calibration Technician under requisition SF-319 in Glendale, Arizona.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J08-claim-2", "original_text": "The listed base salary is $28,000 to $34,000 per year.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J08-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Compensation: hourly base pay and overtime exclusion", "source_support": "conflicting", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft adds thousands to the numbers and changes per hour to per year. This changes the pay, not just how it looks.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "The listed base pay is $28 to $34 per hour, excluding overtime payments.", "recheck_instruction": "Check both ends of the pay range, the currency, the hourly unit, and the base-pay limit. Check the pay fields and the text readers see." }, { "claim_id": "practice-J08-claim-3", "original_text": "The full-time schedule is 40 hours per week.", "source_ids": [ "practice-J08-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Schedule: full-time and scheduled weekly hours", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The source gives these scheduled hours. They do not tell us how many weeks are paid or what someone earns in a year.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "The full-time schedule is 40 hours per week.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Solstice Finch Metrology is hiring a Calibration Technician under requisition SF-319 in Glendale, Arizona. The listed base pay is $28 to $34 per hour, excluding overtime payments. The full-time schedule is 40 hours per week.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "You may show a yearly calculation only if it is clearly labeled and states the assumed paid weeks and hours. Do not call it the employer's stated annual salary. Keeping the source's hourly pay is simpler." ], "unresolved_issues": [], "lesson": "A pay figure needs its currency, time unit, range, and limits. Keeping only the digits does not keep the meaning." } }, { "case_id": "practice-D01", "short_id": "D01", "content_type": "company_directory", "title": "Unsupported AI business label", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a company profile based on facts for readers looking into Arizona businesses.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "Readers checking what a company does and what kind of presence it has in Arizona.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-D01-source-1", "title": "Services and workshop", "publisher": "Copper Kite Field Services", "url": "https://copper-kite-field-services.example/services", "publication_date": "2026-10-02", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Services page: Industrial maintenance and Arizona workshop", "text": "Industrial maintenance\nCopper Kite Field Services maintains industrial water-monitoring equipment for customers.\nArizona workshop\nThe company operates a service workshop in Tempe, Arizona. This page describes equipment maintenance services and workshop operations.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-copper-kite-field-services", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This passage supports the listed services and workshop. It does not support a software or model product it never mentions." }, { "source_id": "practice-D01-source-2", "title": "How we organize maintenance notes", "publisher": "Copper Kite Field Services", "url": "https://copper-kite-field-services.example/operations/maintenance-notes", "publication_date": "2026-10-05", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Operations note: third-party language-model product and its use", "text": "Our technicians use a third-party hosted language-model product to organize maintenance notes.\nTechnicians review those notes before including them in customer maintenance records.\nThis operations note describes our use of purchased software. It contains no statement that we develop a model or license a model platform to customers.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-copper-kite-field-services", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This is the company's own account of how it uses a tool. The lack of a model-building claim here does not prove the company has no other activities." } ], "draft": "Copper Kite Field Services develops proprietary foundation models for industrial customers. The company maintains industrial water-monitoring equipment. It operates a service workshop in Tempe, Arizona. Its technicians use a third-party language-model product to organize maintenance notes. Its model platform is available for licensing.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": true, "answer": { "summary": "Keep the model-building and licensing claims on Hold. The sources support industrial maintenance and a stated use of another company's AI tool. Those are different activities. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-D01-claim-1", "original_text": "Copper Kite Field Services develops proprietary foundation models for industrial customers.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D01-source-1", "practice-D01-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Source 1: Industrial maintenance; source 2: purchased software use", "source_support": "unsupported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "Neither source shows that the company builds its own AI models. Using an AI product is different from making one. The wrong business label could change a reader's choice.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "The supplied company materials describe a maintenance provider using a third-party AI product; they do not establish a proprietary model-development business.", "recheck_instruction": "Check the narrower description against both pages. Remove model-builder labels and platform claims from the profile and other fields. Do not turn missing evidence into a claim that the company never builds AI." }, { "claim_id": "practice-D01-claim-2", "original_text": "The company maintains industrial water-monitoring equipment.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D01-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Industrial maintenance: described service", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The company describes this service. You can report it as a statement from the supplied company material.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "The company maintains industrial water-monitoring equipment.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-D01-claim-3", "original_text": "It operates a service workshop in Tempe, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D01-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Arizona workshop: city and site function", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The source shows a service workshop in Tempe. It does not call it an AI research center or a chip factory.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "It operates a service workshop in Tempe, Arizona.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-D01-claim-4", "original_text": "Its technicians use a third-party language-model product to organize maintenance notes.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D01-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Operations note: first sentence", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The source describes a specific use of another company's AI tool. That does not mean it builds its own models.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Its technicians use a third-party language-model product to organize maintenance notes.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-D01-claim-5", "original_text": "Its model platform is available for licensing.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D01-source-1", "practice-D01-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Both complete supplied passages: no model platform or licensing offer", "source_support": "unsupported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "No source gives a platform, product release, or licensing offer. This claim invents something the company sells.", "resolution_action": "removed", "corrected_text": "", "recheck_instruction": "Check that the final text and product or category fields no longer claim model-platform licensing. Keep the original issue in the review history." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Copper Kite Field Services maintains industrial water-monitoring equipment and operates a service workshop in Tempe, Arizona. Its technicians use a third-party language-model product to organize maintenance notes. The supplied company materials do not establish a proprietary model-development business or model platform for licensing.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "If the directory lists only AI builders, leave this company out until suitable evidence shows it qualifies. That is a choice about the directory's scope. It does not prove the company never builds AI.", "For a broader directory, keep the supported maintenance description and state exactly how the company uses AI." ], "unresolved_issues": [ "Activities outside these sources are unknown. Do not assume they exist or do not exist." ], "lesson": "Base a company's category on the work the evidence supports. Using an AI product does not by itself make a company an AI model builder." } }, { "case_id": "practice-D02", "short_id": "D02", "content_type": "company_directory", "title": "A plan treated as a working site", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a company profile based on facts for readers looking into Arizona businesses.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "Readers checking what a company does and what kind of presence it has in Arizona.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-D02-source-1", "title": "Proposed Goodyear packaging facility", "publisher": "Quartz Tern Packaging", "url": "https://quartz-tern-packaging.example/news/goodyear-proposal", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Company project update: Business, Stage, Target, and Employment estimate", "text": "Business\nQuartz Tern Packaging supplies semiconductor packaging materials.\nStage\nAs of October 6, 2026, the proposed Goodyear, Arizona, facility is in the planning stage. Construction has not begun.\nTarget\nThe company is targeting a 2028 opening, subject to financing and permits.\nEmployment estimate\nIf developed as proposed, the facility could support up to 500 jobs. This is a projected maximum, not a current employment count.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-quartz-tern-packaging", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This is the company's report of its plans and estimate. It does not prove that construction is done, the site is running, funding is assured, the opening date is firm, or the jobs exist." } ], "draft": "Quartz Tern Packaging supplies semiconductor packaging materials. It operates a semiconductor packaging facility in Goodyear, Arizona. The Goodyear operation has already created 500 jobs and is guaranteed to reach full operation in 2028.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "Keep Hold because the draft turns an unbuilt plan and a possible job count into a working site with existing jobs. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-D02-claim-1", "original_text": "Quartz Tern Packaging supplies semiconductor packaging materials.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D02-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Business: supplied activity", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The business description supports the materials work. It does not show that the planned local site is running.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Quartz Tern Packaging supplies semiconductor packaging materials.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-D02-claim-2", "original_text": "It operates a semiconductor packaging facility in Goodyear, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D02-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Stage: planning and construction not begun", "source_support": "conflicting", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft turns a planned site into a working one. Readers could wrongly think local production is already available.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "The company says its proposed Goodyear, Arizona, facility remains in the planning stage as of October 6, 2026; construction has not begun.", "recheck_instruction": "Keep who made the statement, the planning stage, and the review date. Check that location fields do not label the planned site as running." }, { "claim_id": "practice-D02-claim-3", "original_text": "The Goodyear operation has already created 500 jobs and is guaranteed to reach full operation in 2028.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D02-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Target and Employment estimate: conditions, target year, and projected maximum", "source_support": "conflicting", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The source gives a target opening date with conditions and up to 500 possible jobs. It supports neither current jobs nor a promised opening.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "It targets a 2028 opening, subject to financing and permits, and projects that the proposed facility could support up to 500 jobs.", "recheck_instruction": "Check each distinction: target or promise, possible or existing jobs, up to or exactly. Keep every stated condition. Check that the full new description still describes a plan." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Quartz Tern Packaging supplies semiconductor packaging materials. The company says its proposed Goodyear, Arizona, facility remains in the planning stage as of October 6, 2026; construction has not begun. It targets a 2028 opening, subject to financing and permits, and projects that the proposed facility could support up to 500 jobs.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "List the company's supported business activity. Put the Goodyear proposal in a separate field labeled as a plan.", "Leave out the target date or job estimate if the directory needs only confirmed sites that are running now." ], "unresolved_issues": [], "lesson": "A planned site, a site under construction, and a site that is running are different facts. Keep possible future jobs separate from existing jobs." } }, { "case_id": "practice-D03", "short_id": "D03", "content_type": "company_directory", "title": "Mixing up related companies", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a company profile based on facts for readers looking into Arizona businesses.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "Readers checking what a company does and what kind of presence it has in Arizona.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-D03-source-1", "title": "Group companies and locations", "publisher": "Larkspur Helix Group", "url": "https://larkspur-helix-group.example/group-companies", "publication_date": "2026-10-03", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Group overview: Parent, Cairnwing Sensors, and Thimble Arc Automation entries", "text": "Parent\nLarkspur Helix Group has its headquarters in Flagstaff, Arizona.\nCairnwing Sensors\nOur subsidiary Cairnwing Sensors makes ceramic sensor housings. Its headquarters and manufacturing operation are in Tucson, Arizona.\nThimble Arc Automation\nOur subsidiary Thimble Arc Automation develops industrial scheduling software in San Diego, California.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-larkspur-helix-group", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. The group page gives different places and work for the parent and each company it owns. Shared ownership does not make those facts apply to every company." }, { "source_id": "practice-D03-source-2", "title": "Company profile", "publisher": "Cairnwing Sensors", "url": "https://cairnwing-sensors.example/company", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Profile: legal company, product, and Tucson operation", "text": "Cairnwing Sensors is a subsidiary of Larkspur Helix Group.\nWe make ceramic sensor housings at our Tucson, Arizona, operation, which also serves as our headquarters.\nThis profile concerns Cairnwing Sensors, not the activities of other group companies.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-larkspur-helix-group", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This company's own page confirms its name and work. It is part of the same group, so it is not a separate outside check of the parent's claims." } ], "draft": "Cairnwing Sensors develops industrial scheduling software. Its headquarters are in Flagstaff, Arizona. The company makes ceramic sensor housings in Tucson, Arizona.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "Keep Hold because the draft gives one company the work of a related company and the headquarters of their parent company. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-D03-claim-1", "original_text": "Cairnwing Sensors develops industrial scheduling software.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D03-source-1", "practice-D03-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Source 1: Thimble Arc Automation entry; source 2: Cairnwing product description", "source_support": "unsupported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The scheduling software belongs to a related company. The source supports that work for the other company, not the one listed here.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "Cairnwing Sensors makes ceramic sensor housings and is a subsidiary of Larkspur Helix Group.", "recheck_instruction": "Match each activity you keep to the exact company named in the source. Remove the related company's software work from Cairnwing's description and categories." }, { "claim_id": "practice-D03-claim-2", "original_text": "Its headquarters are in Flagstaff, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D03-source-1", "practice-D03-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Source 1: Parent and Cairnwing entries; source 2: Tucson headquarters", "source_support": "conflicting", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "Flagstaff is the parent's headquarters. Both sources put Cairnwing's headquarters in Tucson. Being owned by the parent does not give it the same location.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "Cairnwing Sensors has its headquarters and manufacturing operation in Tucson, Arizona.", "recheck_instruction": "Check the company name and what it does at that site together. Make sure the final location fields describe Cairnwing, not its parent." }, { "claim_id": "practice-D03-claim-3", "original_text": "The company makes ceramic sensor housings in Tucson, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D03-source-1", "practice-D03-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Source 1: Cairnwing entry; source 2: product and operation", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "Both sources give this work and location to the right company. But both come from the same ownership group. Do not call them separate outside reports.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "The company makes ceramic sensor housings in Tucson, Arizona.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Cairnwing Sensors, a subsidiary of Larkspur Helix Group, makes ceramic sensor housings. Its headquarters and manufacturing operation are in Tucson, Arizona.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "To describe the whole group, name the parent and state which company does each activity at each site. This changes which company the entry describes, so it needs a new review." ], "unresolved_issues": [], "lesson": "Related companies are still separate companies. Check who does the work and who uses each site before you combine their descriptions." } }, { "case_id": "practice-D04", "short_id": "D04", "content_type": "company_directory", "title": "Overstating a local presence", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a company profile based on facts for readers looking into Arizona businesses.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "Readers checking what a company does and what kind of presence it has in Arizona.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-D04-source-1", "title": "Contact and services", "publisher": "Juniper Prism Simulations", "url": "https://juniper-prism-simulations.example/contact", "publication_date": "2026-10-01", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Contact page: Mailing correspondence and Services", "text": "Mailing correspondence\nPhoenix, Arizona. This correspondence address uses a third-party mail-forwarding service.\nServices\nJuniper Prism Simulations offers engineering simulation studies for industrial prototypes.\nThis contact page contains no description of a staffed office or laboratory at the correspondence address.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-juniper-prism-simulations", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. The address is only for mail. A real city name does not prove there are local staff, a lab, or a working site." }, { "source_id": "practice-D04-source-2", "title": "Arizona service area", "publisher": "Juniper Prism Simulations", "url": "https://juniper-prism-simulations.example/service-area/arizona", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Service-area description: Arizona customers and remote delivery", "text": "Juniper Prism Simulations supports customers across Arizona.\nEngineering simulation studies are delivered remotely.\nThis page describes customer coverage; it does not identify an Arizona company facility.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-juniper-prism-simulations", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. Serving Arizona customers does not prove the company has a site there. These sources do not settle whether it has another site they do not mention." } ], "draft": "Juniper Prism Simulations offers engineering simulation studies for industrial prototypes. The company operates an engineering laboratory in Phoenix, Arizona. It supports customers across Arizona through remotely delivered studies.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "Keep the local-lab claim on Hold. The sources show remote service for Arizona customers and a mailing address. They do not show a working site. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-D04-claim-1", "original_text": "Juniper Prism Simulations offers engineering simulation studies for industrial prototypes.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D04-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Services: stated offering", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "This work matches the service description. You can keep it without claiming there is a physical lab.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Juniper Prism Simulations offers engineering simulation studies for industrial prototypes.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-D04-claim-2", "original_text": "The company operates an engineering laboratory in Phoenix, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D04-source-1", "practice-D04-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Source 1: Mailing correspondence; source 2: service area and delivery", "source_support": "unsupported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "A mail-forwarding address and service area do not prove there is an engineering lab. Neither source names local staff or a site. The lab claim lacks support, but that does not prove there is no Arizona site.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "The supplied pages identify a Phoenix correspondence address and Arizona service coverage, but do not establish an Arizona operating facility.", "recheck_instruction": "Replace facility and Phoenix-based labels with the narrower mailing-address or service-area description. Do not claim the company has no Arizona operations just because proof of a site is missing." }, { "claim_id": "practice-D04-claim-3", "original_text": "It supports customers across Arizona through remotely delivered studies.", "source_ids": [ "practice-D04-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Service-area description: customer coverage and remote delivery", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The source says the company serves Arizona customers remotely. That is useful for a directory when this limit stays clear.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "It supports customers across Arizona through remotely delivered studies.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Juniper Prism Simulations offers engineering simulation studies for industrial prototypes and supports customers across Arizona through remotely delivered studies. The supplied pages identify a Phoenix correspondence address but do not establish an Arizona operating facility.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "If this directory requires a working Arizona site, keep the entry pending until suitable evidence shows one.", "For a service-area directory, leave out the mailing city. State that the company serves customers remotely without suggesting a local site." ], "unresolved_issues": [ "The sources do not show whether Juniper Prism has other Arizona premises. A claim about a site needs more evidence." ], "lesson": "A service area, mailing address, office, and production site mean different things. Name only the kind of presence the evidence supports." } }, { "case_id": "practice-N01", "short_id": "N01", "content_type": "business_news", "title": "A company claim copied by other sites", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a short business news item. Make clear what a source reports and what evidence confirms.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "Readers trying to understand a business announcement or event.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-N01-source-1", "title": "VoltNest preview announcement", "publisher": "Tamarack Relay Computing", "url": "https://tamarack-relay-computing.example/news/voltnest-preview", "publication_date": "2026-10-05", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Original announcement: Preview, Internal results, and Evidence limits", "text": "Preview\nTamarack Relay Computing announced a preview of its VoltNest compiler on October 5, 2026.\nInternal results\nThe company reports up to 40% lower energy use during its own tests on three internally selected workloads, compared with its previous compiler version.\nEvidence limits\nThe measurement concerns energy used during the reported runs. The announcement supplies no independent laboratory validation and makes no claim about all customer workloads.\nThe software is described as a preview.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-tamarack-relay-announcement-20261005", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This is the company's report of its own comparison. It supports a careful account of what the company says. It is not separate proof of wider performance." }, { "source_id": "practice-N01-source-2", "title": "VoltNest announcement republished", "publisher": "Juniper Circuit Bulletin", "url": "https://juniper-circuit-bulletin.example/releases/voltnest", "publication_date": "2026-10-05", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Release credit and reproduced results paragraph", "text": "Release credit: Supplied by Tamarack Relay Computing. This page republishes the company's October 5, 2026 VoltNest announcement.\nTamarack Relay Computing reports up to 40% lower energy use during its own tests on three internally selected workloads, compared with its previous compiler version.\nNo additional testing or independent reporting is included in this item.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-tamarack-relay-announcement-20261005", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This page credits and copies source 1. It adds no new source of evidence." }, { "source_id": "practice-N01-source-3", "title": "Company release: VoltNest preview", "publisher": "Mesa Copperwire Digest", "url": "https://mesa-copperwire-digest.example/company-releases/voltnest", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Attribution note and reproduced announcement", "text": "Attribution note: Reproduced from the Tamarack Relay Computing announcement dated October 5, 2026.\nThe company announced a VoltNest compiler preview and reports up to 40% lower energy use in an internal comparison on three selected workloads against its previous compiler.\nThis is a reproduced company release. The digest did not conduct performance tests for this item.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-tamarack-relay-announcement-20261005", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This is another copy of the same company claim. A different domain and date do not make it a separate check." } ], "draft": "Tamarack Relay Computing announced a preview of VoltNest on October 5, 2026. Independent tests prove VoltNest reduces energy use by 40%. Three independent reports confirm the result. The company compared the preview compiler with its previous version on three internally selected workloads. The announcement describes the software as a preview.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": true, "answer": { "summary": "Keep Hold on the claims of separate proof and outside confirmation. Several sites repeat one company report. You may report what the company said if the wording and limits are clear. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-N01-claim-1", "original_text": "Tamarack Relay Computing announced a preview of VoltNest on October 5, 2026.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N01-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Original announcement: Preview", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The company's dated statement supports what it announced and when. It does not prove a result beyond that announcement.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Tamarack Relay Computing announced a preview of VoltNest on October 5, 2026.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-N01-claim-2", "original_text": "Independent tests prove VoltNest reduces energy use by 40%.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N01-source-1", "practice-N01-source-2", "practice-N01-source-3" ], "evidence_locator": "Source 1: Internal results and Evidence limits; sources 2 and 3: company-release credit", "source_support": "unsupported", "source_suitability": "limited_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "All the supplied material comes from the company's own test. The draft removes up to, drops the limit to selected workloads, and invents separate proof. These changes overstate what the evidence shows.", "resolution_action": "qualified", "corrected_text": "Tamarack Relay Computing reports up to 40% lower energy use in its internal comparison on three selected workloads against its previous compiler version.", "recheck_instruction": "Check the new words as a report of what the company says. Keep up to, the internal test, selected workloads, and the comparison baseline. Judge whether the source fits this report, not a claim of separate proof." }, { "claim_id": "practice-N01-claim-3", "original_text": "Three independent reports confirm the result.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N01-source-1", "practice-N01-source-2", "practice-N01-source-3" ], "evidence_locator": "Source 1: original issuer; source 2: Release credit; source 3: Attribution note", "source_support": "unsupported", "source_suitability": "limited_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The two other pages say they repeat the same announcement. Three pages share one source for this result. They add no separate test.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "The other two supplied pages reproduce the same company announcement and do not provide independent confirmation.", "recheck_instruction": "Trace each copy to source 1 and keep the shared source group. Check that the final article does not call the copies separate studies or independent checks." }, { "claim_id": "practice-N01-claim-4", "original_text": "The company compared the preview compiler with its previous version on three internally selected workloads.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N01-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Internal results: baseline and workload selection", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The source supports a report of the company's test. The word company tells readers who did the testing.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "The company compared the preview compiler with its previous version on three internally selected workloads.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-N01-claim-5", "original_text": "The announcement describes the software as a preview.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N01-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Preview and final sentence", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft keeps the product's stage clear. Do not turn this announcement into a full public release or a promise about customer results.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "The announcement describes the software as a preview.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Tamarack Relay Computing announced a preview of VoltNest on October 5, 2026. The company reports up to 40% lower energy use in its internal comparison on three selected workloads against its previous compiler version. The supplied materials contain no independent validation; the other two pages reproduce the same company announcement.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "Leave out the performance number and report only the preview announcement.", "You may keep the result as a company claim with its stated test limits. After review, this narrower wording does not need an automatic Hold just because there is no separate outside check." ], "unresolved_issues": [ "No separate evidence here confirms the performance or shows that it applies to other workloads. Keep those limits clear in the corrected news item." ], "lesson": "Count where evidence starts, not how many web pages repeat it. A company statement can support a report of what the company says. It does not prove someone else confirmed the result." } }, { "case_id": "practice-N02", "short_id": "N02", "content_type": "business_news", "title": "A possible deal treated as complete", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a short business news item. Make clear what a source reports and what evidence confirms.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "Readers trying to understand a business announcement or event.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-N02-source-1", "title": "Proposed transaction announcement", "publisher": "Desert Lantern Microdevices and Morrowloop Packaging", "url": "https://desert-lantern-microdevices.example/news/proposed-morrowloop-transaction", "publication_date": "2026-10-04", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Joint announcement: memorandum date and conditions", "text": "Desert Lantern Microdevices and Morrowloop Packaging signed a nonbinding memorandum on October 4, 2026 concerning a proposed acquisition of Morrowloop Packaging.\nAny acquisition remains subject to financing, due diligence, and both boards' approvals.\nThe companies say they expect a December closing if those conditions are completed. The memorandum does not transfer ownership.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-desert-lantern-morrowloop-joint-announcement", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. The announcement supports a proposed deal and an expected date with conditions. It does not prove the purchase is done or promise a closing date." }, { "source_id": "practice-N02-source-2", "title": "Transaction status update", "publisher": "Desert Lantern Microdevices and Morrowloop Packaging", "url": "https://desert-lantern-microdevices.example/news/morrowloop-status", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Status update: no completed transfer as of October 6", "text": "As of October 6, 2026, the proposed Morrowloop Packaging acquisition remains under review.\nNo ownership transfer has been completed. The conditions stated in the October 4 nonbinding memorandum remain in place.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-desert-lantern-morrowloop-joint-announcement", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This gives the current status in the case. It does not predict whether the deal will close." } ], "draft": "Desert Lantern Microdevices has acquired Morrowloop Packaging. The companies signed a nonbinding memorandum on October 4, 2026. They say they expect a December closing if financing, due diligence, and both boards' approvals are completed.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "Keep Hold because the first sentence turns a proposed deal with conditions into a completed purchase. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-N02-claim-1", "original_text": "Desert Lantern Microdevices has acquired Morrowloop Packaging.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N02-source-1", "practice-N02-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Source 1: proposed acquisition and no transfer; source 2: status update", "source_support": "conflicting", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft says the purchase is complete. But the early agreement is nonbinding, and the update says ownership has not changed. The announcement date is not a completion date.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "Desert Lantern Microdevices and Morrowloop Packaging announced a proposed acquisition; their October 6 update says no ownership transfer has been completed.", "recheck_instruction": "Use the current update to check the deal's stage. Check the headline, verb tense, and body for any remaining claim that the purchase is complete." }, { "claim_id": "practice-N02-claim-2", "original_text": "The companies signed a nonbinding memorandum on October 4, 2026.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N02-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Joint announcement: first sentence", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "This is the date the companies signed a nonbinding early agreement, not the date the purchase closed. The draft keeps that sentence accurate.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "The companies signed a nonbinding memorandum on October 4, 2026.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-N02-claim-3", "original_text": "They say they expect a December closing if financing, due diligence, and both boards' approvals are completed.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N02-source-1", "practice-N02-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Source 1: conditional expected closing; source 2: conditions remain in place", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft names who expects this outcome and keeps the conditions. It does not promise that it will happen in December.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "They say they expect a December closing if financing, due diligence, and both boards' approvals are completed.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Desert Lantern Microdevices and Morrowloop Packaging signed a nonbinding memorandum on October 4, 2026 concerning a proposed acquisition. Their October 6 update says no ownership transfer has been completed. They say they expect a December closing if financing, due diligence, and both boards' approvals are completed.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "You could report only that the companies signed a nonbinding memorandum. Leave out the expected closing month if the short item does not need it." ], "unresolved_issues": [], "lesson": "Keep the event, announcement date, deal stage, and future conditions separate. A dated announcement does not make a proposed deal complete." } }, { "case_id": "practice-N03", "short_id": "N03", "content_type": "business_news", "title": "Changed numbers or dates covered", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a short business news item. Make clear what a source reports and what evidence confirms.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "Readers trying to understand a business announcement or event.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-N03-source-1", "title": "Member business survey: September 2026", "publisher": "Mesa Copperline Association", "url": "https://mesa-copperline-association.example/research/september-2026-survey", "publication_date": "2026-09-30", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Survey report: September table, July comparison, and Scope notes", "text": "September table\nSurvey period: September 2026. Respondents: 120 member businesses.\nThirty respondents reported using generative AI tools during September, equivalent to 25% of respondents.\nJuly comparison\nIn July 2026, 20 of 100 responding member businesses reported use, equivalent to 20%.\nScope notes\nParticipation was voluntary. The September and July respondent groups were not identical.\nThese figures describe the responding members for each month; they do not estimate all Arizona businesses or change within a fixed panel.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-mesa-copperline-association", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This is the original report of a voluntary survey of members. It does not show results for the whole population, change in the same businesses, cause and effect, or a full-year rate." } ], "draft": "Twenty-five percent of all Arizona businesses used generative AI in 2026. Thirty responding member businesses reported using generative AI tools during September. Compared with July's 20% share, the September 25% share represents a five percent increase.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "Keep Hold because the draft changes who the survey covers and its time period. It also mixes up percent and percentage points. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-N03-claim-1", "original_text": "Twenty-five percent of all Arizona businesses used generative AI in 2026.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N03-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "September table and Scope notes", "source_support": "unsupported", "source_suitability": "limited_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft changes the group from 120 members who chose to respond to all Arizona businesses. It also changes September to the whole year 2026. This survey cannot support that statewide annual claim.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "In the association's September 2026 survey, 25% of 120 responding member businesses reported using generative AI tools that month.", "recheck_instruction": "Check the math for 30 out of 120, who answered, what they reported, and the September period. Check that the source fits the narrower survey claim." }, { "claim_id": "practice-N03-claim-2", "original_text": "Thirty responding member businesses reported using generative AI tools during September.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N03-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "September table: count, self-report, and month", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The count and monthly measure correctly cover only the members who responded. The answers are what those members reported.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Thirty responding member businesses reported using generative AI tools during September.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-N03-claim-3", "original_text": "Compared with July's 20% share, the September 25% share represents a five percent increase.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N03-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "July comparison and Scope notes", "source_support": "conflicting", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The gap is five percentage points, not a five percent increase. Different groups answered the two surveys. The result does not measure change in the same businesses.", "resolution_action": "corrected", "corrected_text": "The reported share was five percentage points higher than July's 20%, but the respondent groups differ, so this does not establish change among the same businesses.", "recheck_instruction": "Subtract 20 from 25 to get five percentage points. Keep the warning that different groups answered. Do not call this a statewide trend or growth in the same businesses." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "In the Mesa Copperline Association's September 2026 survey, 30 of 120 responding member businesses, or 25%, reported using generative AI tools that month. The reported share was five percentage points higher than July's 20%. Participation was voluntary and the respondent groups differed, so these figures do not establish statewide prevalence or change among the same businesses.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "Leave out the July comparison. Report the September count and share, and say the survey covers members who chose to answer.", "You can calculate a 25% relative difference with (25 - 20) / 20. But it is not a growth rate for Arizona or for the same businesses. Percentage points are clearer here." ], "unresolved_issues": [ "This survey does not estimate results for all Arizona businesses. It also does not follow the same group over time." ], "lesson": "Check the number, total, measure, group, and time period together. Correct math can still lead to a claim the evidence does not support." } }, { "case_id": "practice-N04", "short_id": "N04", "content_type": "business_news", "title": "A source that does not fit the claim", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a short business news item. Make clear what a source reports and what evidence confirms.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "Readers trying to understand a business announcement or event.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-N04-source-1", "title": "PF-4 optical alignment fixture", "publisher": "Pinyon Harbor Fabrication", "url": "https://pinyon-harbor-fabrication.example/products/PF-4", "publication_date": "2026-10-02", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Product page: Product family and PF-4 description", "text": "Product family\nPinyon Harbor Fabrication makes optical alignment fixtures for equipment assembly.\nPF-4\nThe PF-4 fixture supports repeatable alignment of optical modules during assembly.\nThis product page contains product information only; it includes no funding award, grant date, or grant amount.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-pinyon-harbor-fabrication", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This case identifies the page as the company's real product page. That does not make it evidence for an unrelated grant." }, { "source_id": "practice-N04-source-2", "title": "Company location", "publisher": "Pinyon Harbor Fabrication", "url": "https://pinyon-harbor-fabrication.example/company", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Company profile: Mesa operation", "text": "Pinyon Harbor Fabrication operates in Mesa, Arizona.\nThe company profile describes equipment-assembly fixtures.\nNo grant or funding announcement is included in the supplied profile.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-pinyon-harbor-fabrication", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. The sources support the company's location and work. They give no grant agency, award record, or company funding announcement." } ], "draft": "Pinyon Harbor Fabrication makes optical alignment fixtures for equipment assembly. The company received a $7 million state grant on October 1, 2026. Its PF-4 fixture supports repeatable alignment of optical modules during assembly.", "contains_seeded_material_error": true, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "Keep the funding claim on Hold because the linked pages do not report an award. If you remove that claim, decide whether the product description left over still works as news. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-N04-claim-1", "original_text": "Pinyon Harbor Fabrication makes optical alignment fixtures for equipment assembly.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N04-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Product family: stated activity", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The product page is a suitable source and directly supports this description.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Pinyon Harbor Fabrication makes optical alignment fixtures for equipment assembly.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-N04-claim-2", "original_text": "The company received a $7 million state grant on October 1, 2026.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N04-source-1", "practice-N04-source-2" ], "evidence_locator": "Both complete supplied passages: no grant, amount, date, or award record", "source_support": "unsupported", "source_suitability": "limited_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "These real company pages do not show any grant. A working page or the right company name cannot supply a missing award, amount, date, or agency. This gap does not prove there was no grant.", "resolution_action": "removed", "corrected_text": "", "recheck_instruction": "Remove the grant claim from the headline, body, and summary fields, or get suitable award evidence before writing a new claim. Check the removal. Keep the original unsupported claim in the history." }, { "claim_id": "practice-N04-claim-3", "original_text": "Its PF-4 fixture supports repeatable alignment of optical modules during assembly.", "source_ids": [ "practice-N04-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "PF-4: product description", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The words match the company's product description. Do not present them as a separate test of performance.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Its PF-4 fixture supports repeatable alignment of optical modules during assembly.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Pinyon Harbor Fabrication describes its products as optical alignment fixtures for equipment assembly. Its product page says the PF-4 supports repeatable alignment of optical modules during assembly.", "initial_readiness": "hold_until_resolved", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Keep Hold until the required evidence and checks are complete, every kept Material claim is covered, and each needed fix or removal has been checked again.", "Choose Ready for human approval after saving the corrected version, its evidence, and the full list of Material claims and their checks. A named human must still make the approval decision.", "Choose Withdraw or reject if the publisher cannot fix the Material issue for this use." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "Withdraw the news item if removing the unsupported grant leaves no useful news event.", "Use the supported product description in a company entry with its own review.", "For a future funding claim, get an actual award record or a suitable announcement that you clearly name as the source. No such evidence is supplied here." ], "unresolved_issues": [ "These sources do not settle whether a grant was awarded. Do not turn missing evidence into a claim that no grant exists." ], "lesson": "A real source may have nothing to do with the sentence linked to it. Check the evidence for each claim. A working link alone does not make the claim trustworthy." } }, { "case_id": "practice-C01", "short_id": "C01", "content_type": "job_listing", "title": "Accurate current summary", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a current job listing that sends readers to the right employer opening.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "People deciding whether, where, and how to apply for a job.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-C01-source-1", "title": "Equipment Technician | KL-091", "publisher": "Kestrel Loom Robotics", "url": "https://kestrel-loom-robotics.example/careers/KL-091", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Vacancy: Identity and status, Work, and Compensation", "text": "Identity and status\nEmployer: Kestrel Loom Robotics. Role: Equipment Technician. Requisition: KL-091. Open as of October 6, 2026.\nWork\nFull-time, on-site in Peoria, Arizona.\nCompensation\nBase pay: $30 to $34 per hour.\nThis is the complete supplied text for the listed terms.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-kestrel-loom-robotics", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. This case identifies the page as the employer's current job posting. Its open status has a date. A later real-world use would need a new check." } ], "draft": "Kestrel Loom Robotics lists Equipment Technician requisition KL-091 as open on October 6, 2026. The role is full-time and on-site in Peoria, Arizona. The stated base pay is $30 to $34 per hour.", "contains_seeded_material_error": false, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "No error that could change a reader's choice was added to this case. The draft can be Ready after the normal checks are recorded. The answer key is not a real review or an approval. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-C01-claim-1", "original_text": "Kestrel Loom Robotics lists Equipment Technician requisition KL-091 as open on October 6, 2026.", "source_ids": [ "practice-C01-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Identity and status: employer, role, requisition, and open date", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The employer, job, and dated open status match the case evidence. No error in the identity or current status was added to this case.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Kestrel Loom Robotics lists Equipment Technician requisition KL-091 as open on October 6, 2026.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-C01-claim-2", "original_text": "The role is full-time and on-site in Peoria, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-C01-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Work: employment type, arrangement, and city", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft keeps all the stated job terms. It does not expand where someone may work or promise more remote work.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "The role is full-time and on-site in Peoria, Arizona.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-C01-claim-3", "original_text": "The stated base pay is $30 to $34 per hour.", "source_ids": [ "practice-C01-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Compensation: currency, range, unit, and base-pay status", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The range and hourly base pay match. Do not invent annual pay or add a requirement the sources do not give.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "The stated base pay is $30 to $34 per hour.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Kestrel Loom Robotics lists Equipment Technician requisition KL-091 as open on October 6, 2026. The role is full-time and on-site in Peoria, Arizona. The stated base pay is $30 to $34 per hour.", "initial_readiness": "can_be_ready_after_review", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Choose Ready for human approval after recording the required source checks, reviewer name, check time, and full list of Material claims.", "Only a separate decision by a named human can approve the reviewed version. This practice answer is not that decision.", "Keep Hold if the real publication date is later and no one has checked again that the job is open." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "Keep the draft as it is after recording the evidence checks and full claim list.", "You may put the supported terms in a clearer order without changing their meaning. Then check that new version." ], "unresolved_issues": [], "lesson": "An accurate draft with suitable sources may pass. Do not invent an error or make an unneeded edit just to show that a review took place." } }, { "case_id": "practice-C02", "short_id": "C02", "content_type": "company_directory", "title": "A clear, limited company description", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a company profile based on facts for readers looking into Arizona businesses.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "Readers checking what a company does and what kind of presence it has in Arizona.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-C02-source-1", "title": "Products and Arizona locations", "publisher": "Cairn Acacia Components", "url": "https://cairn-acacia-components.example/company", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Company profile: Products, Machine shop, and Sales support", "text": "Products\nCairn Acacia Components supplies insulating mounts used in semiconductor wafer-handling equipment.\nMachine shop\nIts machining operation is in Mesa, Arizona.\nSales support\nIts sales-support office is in Gilbert, Arizona.\nThe profile describes component supply and those two site functions; it does not claim to fabricate semiconductor chips.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-cairn-acacia-components", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. These are company statements about specific parts and the work done at each site. They do not show chip making, AI model building, or work at sites that are not named." } ], "draft": "Cairn Acacia Components supplies insulating mounts used in semiconductor wafer-handling equipment. It operates a machine shop in Mesa, Arizona. Its sales-support office is in Gilbert, Arizona.", "contains_seeded_material_error": false, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "No error that could change a reader's choice was added to this case. The description stays within what the sources show about the company's work and locations. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-C02-claim-1", "original_text": "Cairn Acacia Components supplies insulating mounts used in semiconductor wafer-handling equipment.", "source_ids": [ "practice-C02-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Products: component and equipment application", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The source supports this specific parts-supplier description. It explains the link to semiconductors without calling the company a chip maker.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Cairn Acacia Components supplies insulating mounts used in semiconductor wafer-handling equipment.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-C02-claim-2", "original_text": "It operates a machine shop in Mesa, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-C02-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Machine shop: Mesa machining operation", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The source supports both the city and the kind of work done there.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "It operates a machine shop in Mesa, Arizona.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-C02-claim-3", "original_text": "Its sales-support office is in Gilbert, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-C02-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Sales support: Gilbert office", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The description keeps the sales office separate from the machining site. That is a useful limit, not a gap to fill with a claim about more work.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Its sales-support office is in Gilbert, Arizona.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Cairn Acacia Components supplies insulating mounts used in semiconductor wafer-handling equipment. It operates a machine shop in Mesa, Arizona. Its sales-support office is in Gilbert, Arizona.", "initial_readiness": "can_be_ready_after_review", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Choose Ready for human approval after recording checks of the stated work, the use of each site, and the final list of claims.", "A named human may approve only the reviewed version through the normal decision step.", "Keep Hold if new evidence or a different use makes a key location or business claim uncertain." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "You may put both locations in one sentence. Keep clear which site does each kind of work.", "You may use semiconductor equipment components as a category if the directory uses it consistently and does not suggest the company makes chips." ], "unresolved_issues": [], "lesson": "A narrow company description can be useful. A precise account of supplied parts is better supported than an inflated label such as chipmaker or AI developer." } }, { "case_id": "practice-C03", "short_id": "C03", "content_type": "business_news", "title": "Clearly reporting a company claim", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a short business news item. Make clear what a source reports and what evidence confirms.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "Readers trying to understand a business announcement or event.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-C03-source-1", "title": "Prototype scheduling test announcement", "publisher": "Copper Wren Acceleration", "url": "https://copper-wren-acceleration.example/news/prototype-test", "publication_date": "2026-10-05", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Announcement: Reported result, Test setting, and Evidence and product limits", "text": "Reported result\nCopper Wren Acceleration says its prototype reduced median scheduling time by 18% in an internal test against its own baseline.\nTest setting\nThe test used synthetic task queues. The result described here concerns that internal test, not customer deployments.\nEvidence and product limits\nThe complete supplied release provides no independent validation. Customer trials are planned.\nAnnouncement date: October 5, 2026.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-copper-wren-acceleration", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. The source supports what the company says about its prototype and test. It does not give separate proof of the result or show how the product works for real customers." } ], "draft": "Copper Wren Acceleration says its prototype reduced median scheduling time by 18% in an internal test against its own baseline. Its October 5, 2026 announcement concerns synthetic task queues, not customer deployments. The supplied release provides no independent validation and describes customer trials as planned.", "contains_seeded_material_error": false, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "No error that could change a reader's choice was added to this case. The company statement fits these limited claims about what it reports. A missing outside check does not automatically require Hold. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-C03-claim-1", "original_text": "Copper Wren Acceleration says its prototype reduced median scheduling time by 18% in an internal test against its own baseline.", "source_ids": [ "practice-C03-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Reported result: full attributed result", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The claim says the company reports this result. The source supports that wording. The draft keeps the prototype stage, median measure, internal test, and company baseline. The company statement fits this use, but it is not separate proof of performance.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Copper Wren Acceleration says its prototype reduced median scheduling time by 18% in an internal test against its own baseline.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-C03-claim-2", "original_text": "Its October 5, 2026 announcement concerns synthetic task queues, not customer deployments.", "source_ids": [ "practice-C03-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Test setting and announcement date", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The sentence stays within what the announced comparison covers. It does not claim to describe all company tests or every use of the product.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Its October 5, 2026 announcement concerns synthetic task queues, not customer deployments.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-C03-claim-3", "original_text": "The supplied release provides no independent validation and describes customer trials as planned.", "source_ids": [ "practice-C03-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Evidence and product limits: both statements", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The statement about missing outside checks applies only to the supplied release. Planned keeps the stage clear. You can accurately report what the company says even if no outside test confirms it.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "The supplied release provides no independent validation and describes customer trials as planned.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Copper Wren Acceleration says its prototype reduced median scheduling time by 18% in an internal test against its own baseline. Its October 5, 2026 announcement concerns synthetic task queues, not customer deployments. The supplied release provides no independent validation and describes customer trials as planned.", "initial_readiness": "can_be_ready_after_review", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Choose Ready for human approval after recording checks of who made each claim, the test limits, and the full list of Material claims.", "A named human may approve only that reviewed version, which clearly names the company as the source.", "Keep Hold if the words change to a broad performance claim without suitable new evidence and checks." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "Keep the number clearly tied to the company, along with its limits, after the normal review.", "You may leave out the promotional number to make a shorter product announcement. That is an editing choice, not a required fix." ], "unresolved_issues": [ "No separate test or real customer result is shown. The draft does not claim either and makes that limit clear." ], "lesson": "Judge the claim the draft actually makes. Saying a company reports a result is different from saying outside evidence proves it. Clear wording about who made the claim can be Ready without pretending that a separate test took place." } }, { "case_id": "practice-C04", "short_id": "C04", "content_type": "job_listing", "title": "Missing pay stated correctly", "evidence_type": "fictional_practice", "fictional_notice": "Made-up practice case. The names, source passages, drafts, and errors are invented. The .example links are teaching examples, not real source pages. All source dates and times, including retrieved_at and review dates, belong to the made-up case. They are not real checks. This is not a report of a real AI or publisher error. The worksheet does not find errors for you.", "intended_use": "Write a current job listing that sends readers to the right employer opening.", "intended_timeframe": "For publication on October 6, 2026, Arizona time. Use only the made-up evidence supplied with this case.", "audience": "People deciding whether, where, and how to apply for a job.", "review_date": "2026-10-06", "source_passages": [ { "source_id": "practice-C04-source-1", "title": "Assembly Documentation Technician | WA-056", "publisher": "Willowpin Assembly", "url": "https://willowpin-assembly.example/careers/WA-056", "publication_date": "2026-10-06", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T10:00:00-07:00", "locator": "Complete supplied vacancy page: Identity and status, Worksite, and Duties", "text": "Identity and status\nEmployer: Willowpin Assembly. Role: Assembly Documentation Technician. Requisition: WA-056. Accepting applications as of October 6, 2026.\nWorksite\nFull-time, on-site in Surprise, Arizona.\nDuties\nPrepare assembly instructions and maintain production documentation.\nEnd of supplied vacancy page.", "source_origin_group": "fictional-willowpin-assembly", "limitations": "Made-up source passage. No real page was opened. The full supplied posting has no salary or hourly-pay field. This finding covers only this posting. It does not show what the employer says elsewhere or what it may offer someone." } ], "draft": "Willowpin Assembly lists Assembly Documentation Technician requisition WA-056 as accepting applications on October 6, 2026. The role is full-time and on-site in Surprise, Arizona. The supplied employer posting does not state salary or hourly pay.", "contains_seeded_material_error": false, "worked": false, "answer": { "summary": "No error that could change a reader's choice was added to this case. The draft correctly says pay is missing from this source. It does not invent an amount or make a claim about every employer document. These notes review the original draft. Suggested changes still need checks. They do not approve the item for publication.", "findings": [ { "claim_id": "practice-C04-claim-1", "original_text": "Willowpin Assembly lists Assembly Documentation Technician requisition WA-056 as accepting applications on October 6, 2026.", "source_ids": [ "practice-C04-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Identity and status: employer, title, requisition, and dated status", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The job identity and dated open status match the posting.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "Willowpin Assembly lists Assembly Documentation Technician requisition WA-056 as accepting applications on October 6, 2026.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-C04-claim-2", "original_text": "The role is full-time and on-site in Surprise, Arizona.", "source_ids": [ "practice-C04-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Worksite: employment type, arrangement, and city", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The draft keeps the stated location and work schedule accurate.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "The role is full-time and on-site in Surprise, Arizona.", "recheck_instruction": "Compare the words you keep with the source passage. Record who checked them and when. Check the final draft too. Mark this as a made-up practice check, not a check of a real source." }, { "claim_id": "practice-C04-claim-3", "original_text": "The supplied employer posting does not state salary or hourly pay.", "source_ids": [ "practice-C04-source-1" ], "evidence_locator": "Complete supplied vacancy page: no compensation field", "source_support": "supported", "source_suitability": "appropriate_for_claim", "timeframe_fit": "fits_stated_timeframe", "materiality": "material", "rationale": "The full posting supports this limited statement about missing pay. It does not mean pay is missing everywhere, the job is unpaid, or the employer never states pay.", "resolution_action": "unchanged_and_supported", "corrected_text": "The supplied employer posting does not state salary or hourly pay.", "recheck_instruction": "Read the full posting. Keep the scope words supplied employer posting. Leave pay values null or blank. Do not add an estimate just to fill a form." } ], "acceptable_final_text": "Willowpin Assembly lists Assembly Documentation Technician requisition WA-056 as accepting applications on October 6, 2026. The role is full-time and on-site in Surprise, Arizona. The supplied employer posting does not state salary or hourly pay.", "initial_readiness": "can_be_ready_after_review", "possible_final_decisions": [ "Choose Ready for human approval after recording checks of the job identity, dated status, terms, and statement that this posting has no pay figure.", "A named human may approve that reviewed version only through the separate decision step.", "Keep Hold if someone later adds a pay estimate without suitable evidence and a new check." ], "alternative_defensible_answers": [ "Leave out the pay sentence. Leave the amount blank and label it Unknown or Not stated in supplied posting.", "Use a separate, clearly labeled pay claim only if you later get suitable evidence for the same role." ], "unresolved_issues": [], "lesson": "Unknown can be an accurate and useful answer. Something missing from one source is not proof that it is missing everywhere. A missing value is not zero." } } ] }